Browsing by Author "Gonzalez-Roca, Fernando"

Now showing 1 - 2 of 2
  • No Thumbnail Available
    Item
    Artisanal fishers' perceptions of two co-existing kelp resource management regimes in northern Chile
    (2023) Gonzalez-Roca, Fernando; Perez-Ruzafa, Angel; Vasquez, Julio A.; Gelcich, Stefan
    As fisheries management evolves and includes new measures, it is imperative to evaluate co-existing regimes. In Chile, two kelp fishery management policies were implemented sequentially over the last 20 years and currently co-exist. We analysed fishers' perceptions regarding the performance of a territorial user rights policy and a regional management plan policy operating in what were historically open access areas along the coastline of two important kelp production regions in northern Chile. Interviews with Directorates of fisher associations were used to report key dimensions of both regimes, their problems, benefits, and proposals for improvement. A survey was used to assess artisanal fishers' perceptions of the outcomes of the two management regimes studied: satisfaction, perceived success, and compliance. Trust, environmental attitude, and participation in decision -making associated to both regimes were also assessed. The results of the interviews show that the majority of association Directorates mentioned illegal harvesting by unregistered fishers as the most important problem of the regional management plan regime and suggest that the state needs to invest in law enforcement as a key issue for improvement. The survey results showed that, in general, the territorial user rights regime is perceived to have higher levels of compliance, success, and generates more satisfaction. Lessons from the different man-agement regimes can provide important insights for improving the implementation of management plans to generate synergies between co-existing management regimes.
  • No Thumbnail Available
    Item
    Exploring the role of access regimes over an economically important intertidal kelp species
    (2021) Gonzalez-Roca, Fernando; Gelcich, Stefan; Perez-Ruzafa, Angel; Alonso Vega, J. M.; Vasquez, Julio A.
    Achieving sustainable use of kelps is key for small-scale fishers' livelihoods and biodiversity. During the last three decades, Chile has implemented different policy approaches to manage kelps. Unfortunately, assessments of the biological impacts of these management regimes have not received the attention they deserve. In this study, we explore biomass, density, size structure and holdfast diameter/stipe length relation of the kelp Lessonia spp., associated to a territorial user rights policy, which grant exclusive access to fishers, and a regional management plan policy which defines control rules in what were historically de facto open access areas. We compare these with marine protected areas where harvesting is banned, thus serving as a benchmark. The study was performed along the coast of two of the main kelp harvesting regions of Chile. The analyses, performed in two time periods, shows that biomass is greater inside areas managed through territorial user rights and in marine protected areas compared to areas where regional management plans have been implemented, which perform in a similar way to open access sites. Enforcement is a key driver of kelp response. Densities of recruits and juveniles are higher in areas where harvesting and gathering are allowed, whilst adult plants have higher density in marine protected areas. In all cases, kelps have become denser after eleven years. The holdfast diameter/stipe length relation provides an indicator of protection efficiency: stricter regulatory measures are related to larger holdfast diameters and shorter stipes. We conclude that, in general, territorial user rights policies and marine protected areas have contributed to the conservation of wild intertidal Lessonia populations. Results highlight the potential of the regional management plans policy to improve kelp management, but it will probably need important adjustments to enhance enforcement and compliance. In addition management innovations such as rotational harvest strategies could provide an important complement which should be further assessed.